As a travel blogger who loves exploring diverse destinations, I often find myself intrigued by places that don’t always receive the best reviews. One such destination that has developed a bit of a reputation over the years is Staten Island, one of New York City’s five boroughs. Staten Island is often overshadowed by the glamour of Manhattan, the cultural richness of Brooklyn, and the urban charm of Queens and the Bronx. But it’s not just a matter of being less popular—Staten Island has a reputation for being, as some might say, “so bad.”
So, why is Staten island so bad? Is it truly as underwhelming as people say, or is it simply misunderstood? After spending time in Staten Island, I want to share an honest and professional travel blogger’s perspective on why this borough often faces criticism, and whether it deserves that reputation.
The Geographic Isolation of Staten Island
One of the first things that sets Staten Island apart from the other New York City boroughs is its geographic isolation. Staten Island is situated to the southwest of Manhattan, across the New York Harbor. Unlike the more easily accessible boroughs, Staten Island requires a bit more effort to reach, especially if you’re coming from Manhattan or Brooklyn.
Limited Public Transportation Options
Perhaps the most notorious aspect of Staten Island’s isolation is its limited public transportation options. While the other boroughs are connected by the sprawling New York City subway system, Staten Island is left out of this network. The only train line on the island is the Staten Island Railway, which runs from the southern tip of the island to the St. George Ferry Terminal on the northern end. However, this railway doesn’t connect to the subway system, which makes commuting to and from Staten Island a challenge for residents and visitors alike.
For those living in or visiting the other boroughs, the only free and convenient way to get to Staten Island is via the Staten Island Ferry. The ferry ride is a scenic 25-minute trip across the harbor, offering beautiful views of the Statue of Liberty and the Manhattan skyline. However, the ferry only operates between Staten Island and Lower Manhattan, meaning that anyone coming from other parts of New York City will face a longer and less direct route to the island.
The limited public transportation options create a sense of isolation that can make Staten Island feel disconnected from the rest of the city. For tourists and residents alike, this lack of connectivity is often cited as one of the reasons why Staten Island is considered “so bad.”
Suburban Character in an Urban City
Another factor that contributes to Staten Island’s less-than-stellar reputation is its suburban character, which contrasts sharply with the urban energy that defines the rest of New York City. While Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx are known for their densely populated neighborhoods, bustling streets, and towering skyscrapers, Staten Island feels like a different world.
A Borough of Strip Malls and Parking Lots
Driving through Staten Island, one of the first things you’ll notice is the prevalence of strip malls, big-box stores, and parking lots. Unlike the charming brownstones of Brooklyn or the iconic high-rises of Manhattan, Staten Island’s architecture is much more suburban. This means that many areas of the island lack the walkable, vibrant streets that so many people associate with New York City.
For those who are used to the fast-paced, pedestrian-friendly environment of the other boroughs, Staten Island’s suburban sprawl can feel underwhelming. Many critics argue that Staten Island lacks the cultural and architectural character that makes New York City so special. It’s not uncommon to hear complaints about the abundance of chain stores and the lack of unique, locally owned businesses.
Reliance on Cars
In keeping with its suburban character, Staten Island is also the most car-dependent borough in New York City. Public transportation options within the borough are limited, and many residents rely on cars to get around. This reliance on cars contributes to a different lifestyle compared to the other boroughs, where public transit, biking, and walking are the norm.
For tourists who are used to exploring New York City on foot or by subway, Staten Island can feel like a logistical headache. The need for a car to fully explore the island makes it less accessible and appealing to visitors who prefer the convenience of public transportation.
Perception of Staten Island’s Politics and Culture
In addition to its geographic isolation and suburban feel, Staten Island is often criticized for its political and cultural differences from the rest of New York City. The island has a reputation for being more conservative than the other boroughs, which can create a sense of cultural disconnection.
Conservative Politics in a Liberal City
Staten Island is widely regarded as the most politically conservative borough in New York City. While the rest of the city tends to lean heavily Democratic, Staten Island has a history of voting for Republican candidates, both in local and national elections. This political divide has contributed to a perception that Staten Island is out of step with the rest of New York City, which is known for its progressive values and policies.
For some residents of the more liberal boroughs, Staten Island’s political leanings are a point of contention. There’s a sense that Staten Island doesn’t fully embrace the diversity and inclusivity that defines much of New York City’s culture. This political divide can lead to negative perceptions of Staten Island, especially among those who value the city’s more progressive identity.
Cultural Homogeneity
In addition to its political differences, Staten Island is often criticized for its relative lack of cultural diversity compared to the other boroughs. While New York City is celebrated as a melting pot of different cultures, languages, and traditions, Staten Island has historically been less diverse.
The borough’s population is predominantly white, and while there are growing immigrant communities, Staten Island lacks the same level of cultural vibrancy found in neighborhoods like Queens’ Jackson Heights or Brooklyn’s Chinatown. For visitors and residents who are drawn to New York City for its multicultural atmosphere, Staten Island can feel like it’s missing a crucial part of what makes the city so dynamic.
See Also: Canary Wharf: A Comprehensive Introduction
Environmental and Infrastructure Issues
Staten Island has also faced criticism for its environmental and infrastructure challenges, which have contributed to the perception that it’s not an ideal place to live or visit.
The Fresh Kills Landfill Legacy
One of the most notorious environmental issues associated with Staten Island is the legacy of the Fresh Kills Landfill. Once the world’s largest landfill, Fresh Kills was Staten Island’s primary dumping ground for decades. The landfill was finally closed in 2001, but its impact on the borough’s reputation persists.
For years, Staten Island was known as the city’s dumping ground, and the stench from the landfill was a constant issue for residents. While Fresh Kills has since been transformed into a massive park, the stigma of being home to the world’s largest landfill has been hard to shake.
Poor Infrastructure and Road Conditions
Another common complaint about Staten Island is its infrastructure. The borough’s roads are notorious for being in poor condition, with potholes and traffic congestion being constant problems. The Staten Island Expressway, in particular, is often cited as one of the worst roads in the city, with heavy traffic and frequent delays.
For residents and visitors alike, navigating Staten Island’s roads can be a frustrating experience. The combination of traffic, road conditions, and the reliance on cars makes getting around the borough feel like more of a chore than an adventure.
The “Forgotten Borough” Syndrome
One of the reasons Staten Island is often viewed negatively is its status as the “forgotten borough.” While Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx receive much of the attention and investment from the city, Staten Island is frequently left out of the conversation.
Lack of Investment and Development
Compared to the other boroughs, Staten Island has seen relatively little investment in terms of development and infrastructure. While neighborhoods in Brooklyn and Queens have experienced gentrification and revitalization, Staten Island has remained largely unchanged. This lack of development has contributed to a sense of neglect, with many residents feeling that the borough is overlooked by city officials.
The lack of investment is also reflected in Staten Island’s cultural scene. Unlike Manhattan or Brooklyn, Staten Island doesn’t have a thriving arts or entertainment district. There are fewer museums, galleries, and cultural institutions, which can make the borough feel less exciting and dynamic than its counterparts.
A Borough with Potential
Despite all of its criticisms, Staten Island is not without its charm. For those willing to explore beyond the negative perceptions, the borough offers beautiful parks, historic landmarks, and a slower pace of life that can be refreshing compared to the hustle and bustle of the other boroughs.
Staten Island is home to some of the most beautiful green spaces in New York City, including the Staten Island Greenbelt and the newly transformed Fresh Kills Park. The Staten Island Ferry also offers one of the best (and free!) views of the Statue of Liberty and the Manhattan skyline. For nature lovers and those looking to escape the city’s frenetic energy, Staten Island can be a welcome retreat.
Conclusion
So, why is Staten Island often considered “so bad”? The borough’s geographic isolation, suburban character, political differences, and infrastructure issues all contribute to its less-than-stellar reputation. Staten Island feels disconnected from the rest of New York City, both physically and culturally, and this has led to a perception that it’s not worth visiting or living in.
However, as a travel blogger who believes in giving every destination a fair chance, I would argue that Staten Island’s bad reputation is only part of the story. While it may not have the same excitement and cultural vibrancy as Manhattan or Brooklyn, Staten Island has its own unique charm and beauty.
Related Topics:
8 Best Things to See in Seattle on a Day Trip
